When a tiger shark threw up a human arm at Coogee Aquarium in 1935 onlookers and police were left perplexed. 

What followed was an investigation into the distinctively tattooed arm, filled with bizarre twists and turns that remains unsolved to this day. This unusual story has now been turned into an immersive murder mystery experience at the Justice And Police Museum, delving into Sydney’s dark 1930’s criminal underworld.

Executive Producer and Director of the Shark Arm Case, Liviu Monsted joined the Daily team to talk about some of the strange clues and colourful characters involved in the case.

The Shark Arm Case will be running from 14 to 30 August 2025 on Thursday, Friday and Saturday evenings at the Justice And Police Museum. Don’t miss this performing investigation into sydney’s dark past and grab your tickets